Make TV election debates happen - establish an Independent Debates Commission
- Parliament:
- 2017–19
- Signatures:
- 143,390
- Responded:
- 23 Oct 2018
The petition
Genuine leaders' debates took place in 2010, but in the next two elections didn't happen. Amend election law to make party leaders take part in a televised debate.
An Independent Debates Commission would take decision making out of the politicians and broadcasters' hands and ensure TV debates become a regular fixture of UK elections.
The government's response
Televised election debates are a matter for political parties. The Government has no plans to change electoral law to make the debates mandatory.
The proposals for a Debates Commission are something to be considered in due course by political parties, closer to any general election in 2022.
Televised election debates took place in the 2010, 2015 and 2017 UK Parliamentary general elections. They form one of many mediums that enable political parties to convey their message to members of the public and address key challenges.
Televised election debates are not mandatory under electoral law. Participating in a televised election debate is down to the discretion of the political party invited to debate. The Government has no plans to change electoral law to make televised elections debates mandatory.
There are many mediums used by political parties to convey their message to members of the public. These include candidate hustings and political canvassing, which enables electoral candidates to debate policies and directly address members of the public in the run up to an election. These are also not mandatory under electoral law.
Any televised material, including televised election debates, is regulated by Ofcom, the independent media regulator, and is subject to the provisions in the Broadcasting Code. Ofcom does not obligate broadcasters to transmit election debates, nor does it have any decision-making role over the editorial format of any programme.
Cabinet Office
Highlighted: the sentence the model picked as the strongest evidence cited.
Debate
Debated in Parliament on 7 Jan 2019. This is shown for context and is not part of the assessment.
Of 14 MPs who spoke in their own right, 8 were for the petition, 3 neutral and 3 against. The government's response: declines.
- For
- Neutral
- Against